Saturday, August 22, 2009

Tim Noble and Sue Webster - Collaborations

Sunset over Manhattan, 2003, cigarette packets, tin cans , wooden bench, air gun pellets, light projector. 75 x 110 x 31 cm.

Kiss of Death, 2003, taxidermy animals, various bones, light projector, metal stand, 180 x 80 x 50 cm

Tim Noble and Sue Webster are partners as well as collaborators. Their work deals with themes of an all consuming western culture, as well as challenging the idea of the artist as a celebrity. In their work Kiss of Death they have used self- portraiture to bring to the foreground these issues. The work comprises of taxidermy animals forming the profiles of the artists as a light projector casts the shadows onto the gallery wall. Another work, dealing more with a consumer society is Sunset Over Manhattan, I think this work speaks for itself.

Images from : Grosenick, Uta, edited. Art Now Vol 2. London: Taschen, 2005.

Thursday, August 20, 2009

Art and the Body: Ron Mueck


Angel- 1997

Big Man- 2000

Its a Girl- 2003(?)

“Ron Mueck's sculpture explains why man has felt the need to invent the idea of a soul”- Craig Raine

Eleanor Heartney has the specific chronological example at work in Art and the Body, of the Feminist movement of the early seventies, she has maintained a careful criteria in the chapter, somewhat developed as a result of the movement, in the discussion of the use of body as medium and as vehicle for the Artist.
An pure understanding will prevent Mueck to be considered unless, his inclusion is qualified as I personally find, that if the feminist movement was to address sexual issues, then the English Punk movement is litmus to the changing attitude toward what is the understanding of Age & Generation in people. You could imagine, in Punk's instance, a particular sense of generational independence toward the custodians of an Empirical England, and coming from their very offspring. This could be as much catalyst for re-evaluation of the social recourse of the age in people, as warranted by the similarly incendiary and unmet Feminist need coming from the very siblings and spouses.
Heartney goes to identify a need to portray the use of the Body in art in “ways that depart sharply from traditional formulas”, an example Ron Mueck's uncanny objects still fall short of, for what is created is a literal representation, despite creativity, of mostly human replication and more to a comprehensive anatomical than to the ephemeral post- modern precept. It is a simple, emotional basis with which Mueck interacts and breaks down boundaries and preconceptions. It is colloquial and private, the language he communicates. It is often humourous, but contains the tragic, serious note of loneliness and alone- ness. Why he does belong to the chapter, is actually self evident and obvious: the continuous study of our “tears and ecstasies”.
Pulling emotional strings, is something Mueck was born into, being the offspring of toymakers, and a career that produced a succession of renowned appearances as puppeteer/ designer and illustrator He developed admirable associations, including that, with the creativity of Jim Henson, and through a unique opportunity was given lord-age in Charles Saatchi's Sensation. This exhibition never was to see day in Australia, Ron Mueck was an Artist who was subsequently offered the highest payment for the work of a living Artist in Australian history, an apology or excuse.
Imagine a puppet, being altogether still, it never loses personality. It has energy, surprise. A talent can find life in any object and give it voice or gesture, so in art it would seem, “the uncanny is considered an effect to be tackled, not skirted.” Alchemist, Ron Mueck, and from something in the stillness and uncanny realism, the lead in the pieces, produces gold – gold in the incessant yet absent whilst present, narration of his lonely and dispossessed and vulnerable characters. Characters impressed with knowledge of both, “the psychological need to give valid force and meaning to the (so perceived) forces of life” and our “deeply ingrained aversion to the lifelike”- contexts in their artistic being and principals dealt with critically in robotics and prosthetic engineering.
According to Mueck, there is a requirement to the production of the work, “Every gesture becomes a means of symbolic expression” as ultimately, this is “the viewers impression of the object”, whether in detail or from a safer vantage distance. Despite being personable “they have work as objects” or be more than that. The characters are overt, pure therefore and are almost wicked, shameless. Symbols of mythology have been eliminated however, these are often the means of such a goal.
He places juxtapositions at a critical depth in the pieces and balances conceptual inquiry in counterpoint to the persona of the investigation's physical presence, ideas such as globalism, in the image of a bundled child or as the politics of a deathbed scene. He will shift the stature and size,From the ornamental to the monumental just so that the gaze returned, will find the viewer in the centre of the circumstances.
Eleanor Heartney writes, the body is “an unusually versatile instrument” but is forever constrained by being involved with “conflicts...over social mores, gender definitions and community standards. The silent inner Monologue of Ron Mueck draws such immediate attention to the plights, the loneliness and vulnerability the absolute absurd madness, “the perils of human condition.”

Heartney, Eleanor. Art and Today. London: Phaidon Press Limited, 2008

Susanna Greeves, Heiner Bastian and Peter- Klaus Schuster, "Ron Mueck", edited by Heiner Bastian, Berlin: Hatje Cantz Verlag, 2005

Sarah Tanguy, "The progress of Big Man, A Conversation with Ron Mueck", Sculpture, Vol. 22, No. 6. July/August 2003, pp. 28-33, www.sculpture.org/documents/.../jul.../mueck/mueck.shtml

David Hanson, Andrew Olney, Ismar A. Pereira, Marge Zielke, "Upending the Uncanny Valley",Arlington: The University of Texas, 2002, http://www.aaai.org/Papers/Workshops/2005/WS-05.../WS05-11-005.pdf

Cindy Stelmackowich,"Life, death and the power of the Real", Canadian Medical Association Journal", http://www.cmaj.ca/cgi/reprint/176/9/1314.pdf

Peter Hill, "The Un-Special effects man", Art and Australia, V-45, No 2 Summer 2007,www.artaustralia.com/images/.../Ron%20Mueck%20Vol45No2.pdf

art and the body

illusion.scene360.com/.../

Body painting is an ancient form of art, used by tribes for camouflage, identification, and rituals. Reemerging as an art movement in the 60’s, body art highlighted the beauty of the human body and broke through the conservative social constraints. Now days we embrace body art through fashion magazines, festivals, support for sport teams etc.
The annual Australian Body Art Festival is held in the sunshine coast each year in May.

Penrith Regional Gallery: Kate Rohde


I went to the gallery today and discovered this Melbourne based artist Kate Rohde. Although her works are quite kitsch they provide a fantastical and wonderous look into wildlife. Her works explore the spiritual, mythological, and symbolic meanings invested in wildlife, and the human desire to create and control nature for educational and aesthetic purposes. Having recently returned from a residency in Arnhem Land, her installations refer to the manifold histories and cultures of collecting, and to the commodification of nature in western society.

Made from a collaboration of different mediums such as papier mache, plasticine and faux fur, she makes these strange, childish environments and encapsulates them in a display case of a highly ornate nature. The works reflect decorative elements typical of Baroque and Rococo style which was an interesting twist.

Her work took me back and reminded me of when i was a young child and all i wanted were things that were pink and glittery! The three pieces i saw could link back to works by Petah Coyne who creates similar environments with the addition of taxidermy animals and flowers.

If any of you are down Penrith way anytime soon i recommend you check it out. Its pretty wicked.

Collaboration Artists

Cicada is a collection of artists who work with landscape - urban, natural, constructed and imagined.
On the web site it is made evident that a combination of results occur, including site-specific installations, performances and interactive pieces.
Cicada also make other bits of sound+image works for theatre, dance and performance projects.

In a street level interactive installation held in Adelaide 2004 by three aussie artists (Video: Kirsten Bradley + Nick Ritar , Audio: Ben Frost) a work was held which explores the delicate balancing act that unfolds when nature ventures into the city. It examines our relationship with the natural world, our desire to cultivate, capture, prune, tend, weed and above all dominate natural processes. It was rightly called Amensal. Amensalism is an association between organisms of two different species in which one is inhibited or destroyed and the other is unaffected. (Encyclopædia Britannica Online)
I really liked the visual organic appeal of this installation and if you were walking down the street, this would stop you dead in your tracks.

http://www.cicada.tv/projects/2004-amensal/amensal.htm

Wednesday, August 19, 2009

PARTICIPATION + MCA Exhibition


Can everyone please read the review for LOUISA BUFARDECI & ZON ITO at the MCA before we meet on Tuesday... it will provide us all with a grounding for the show and aow us all to discuss the work in an informed way.

+
And regarding collaboration - this is a great book for those interested:


Between the Folds


‘Between the Folds’ is a doco that was aired on the ABC on 9.8.09. It is a very interesting look at the art of origami and its uses.

Try to watch the quicktime clip on the website as it will amaze you. The imagery is beautiful.
PS the goateed geek near the end of the clip got his phd at 20..
http://www.greenfusefilms.com/

Postings for the coming week: ON COLLABORATION

Please take a look at this website - I am sure it will help you with your collaboration postings for the coming week.

http://collabarts.org/

In the last 10 years or so collaborative art practices have moved in to the mainstream of cultural production, and collaboration is now largely taken for granted as one of the numerous ways that artists can choose to operate. Despite this, artistic collaboration still raises some interesting and crucial questions about the nature of authorship, authenticity and the artists’ relationships to their works & audiences that inevitably disrupts the persistent and popular image of the artist as a ‘heroic’ solitary figure. While some collaborations have come from a reaction against political and cultural regimes, there are numerous other artists who have chosen to work together as a positive choice for collaboration. Common to most if not all collaborative practices though, is an implicit critique of the idea of the artist as a figure that stands outside of society engaged in an internal singular dialogue.

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Art and Collaboration

I love collaborating. When you find that person that you can interact with to get a more satisfying and pleasing result it is a rush. It is as though a volcano erupts. The blood pumps and the excitement ramps up. To understand someone to this extent is unfortunately rare in my experience, but when it happens it’s addictive. The amount of ideas that can be churned out is unexpected.

Jake and Dinos Chapman is an artist collaboration that I enjoyed seeing recently in the exhibition Classified: Contemporary Art at Tate Britain. Their artwork ended up being my favorite of the exhibition. It is titled The Chapman Family Collection (2002), which was recently purchased by the Tate. The artwork filled a very large, dark room, which when you walked into gave you a very eerie feeling as you quickly saw that you were surrounded by34 wooden totems; all looking at you. Then you realise that they aren’t completely native statues at all. They have been stamped by the global goblin and become happy meal accessories.



www.whitecube.com/artists/chapman/

Art & The Body - Robert Gober

If bodies are objects or things, they are like no others, for they are the centres of perspective, insight, reflection, desire, agency. - Elizabeth Grosz

American sculptor, Robert Gober, explores the psychological implications of the human body through hybrid anatomical forms, fragmented bodies, and architectural and domestic spaces in which the body is absent yet implicit. Gober's language is one of duplicities – male and female, interior and exterior, public and private, animate and inanimate, present and absent. Commenting on Gober's 2007 retrospective at the Schaulager Museum in Switzerland, Roberta Smith notes the artist's ability to combine that which is personal and political, mysterious and accessible.1 Gober, who draws upon a composite of childhood memories and current experiences, describes his work as “formally rigorous but emotionally messy”.2 Gober often sites a composite of personal memories and current experience as a source for his practice, with this reflected in the hybridity and fracture of the objects he creates.


Figure 1: Robert Gober , Untitled Leg, 1989, beeswax, cotton, wood, leather, human hair

In 1989, Gober began what would become a series of disembodied partial limbs with Untitled Leg (Figure 1). The wax “amputation” is a cast of the artist's own leg, embedded with human hairs and dressed with a man's shoe, sock, and partial trouser. The body fragment speaks of absence, of detachment, of loss; the object is loaded with all that is not there. Gober did not place the limb on a pedestal; rather it was installed as if emerging from the gallery wall, describing an uneasy balance between interior and exterior states. Gober's disembodied limbs and appendages imply a psychological fracture. Julia Kristeva writes that in a state of abjection, borders between object and subject cannot be maintained.3 Rooted within the tradition of Freud's uncanny, Untitled Leg is difficult and unsettling because it provokes a reaction in which there is a hesitation in recognising the object as animate or inanimate.4


Figure 2: Robert Gober, Untitled (Candle), 1991, beeswax, human hair, yarn

Gober has spoken of his work as it is informed both by his catholic upbringing and by his homosexuality. In Untitled (Candle) (Figure 2), human hairs embedded in a wax base, provide an ordinary candle with overt phallic connotations. Gober's use of wax in the construction of his body fragments mirrors the transience and impermenance of the human body, with Smithson noting that Gober's objects are imbued with a vulnerability that defines real bodies. The sense of vulnerability is heightened in Untitled (Candle), a work in which a symbol of masculinity and virility is reduced to that which is destined to disintegrate. Gober has written of the impact of the AIDS epidemic, and the struggle that artists faced in expressing that impact within their work.5 Here the hybrid object of the candle/phallus suggests a painful memorial, while simultaneously referring to the corporeality of the symbolism of the Catholic faith, and Gober's uneasy place as a homosexual raised within the Church.


Figure 3: Robert Gober, Untitled, 1991-1993, wood, beeswax, human hair, fabric, paint and shoes

Untitled (Figure 3) takes the form of a lower half of a male body, violently protruding from the gallery wall to impose itself within the space. Arranged facedown, the partial figure evokes a disquieting sense of powerlessness and unease. The surface of the wax figure is punctured with a number of ulcer-like drains. The drain motif is recurring in much of Gober's practice. In this instance it serves to suggest a body that is leaking, the separation between inner and outer broken down, and emphasises the dual nature of the body as both private and public.




1 Roberta Smith, Against Delusion: Robert Gober's Nuts-and-Bolts Americana, The New York Times, August 23 2007, http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/23/arts/design/23gobe.html?_r=1, (accessed August 10 2009)

2 Frances Morris, “Robert Gober” in Rites of Passage: Art at the End of the Century, 96, London: Tate Gallery Publications, 1995

3 Charles Penwarden, “Of Word and Flesh: An interview with Julia Kristeva” in Rites of Passage: Art at the End of the Century, 22, London: Tate Gallery Publications, 1995

4 Ruth Ronen, Aesthetics of Anxiety, 42, New York: SUNY Press, 2009

5 Neal Benezra, “Plumbing Robert Gober” in Distemper: Dissonant Themes in the art of the 1990s, 46, Washington: Smithsonian Institution, 1996


ART AND THE BODY



concepts of the body in art has been something that has been explored by many artists, and as Heartney says in 'art and today' began performance art and also a readily avalible material for artists to use, test and experiment. the body gives us an insight into ourselves and others, our social and moral ideals, values what we find acceptable, unnerving and where we draw boundries or push them to the limits. It is a subject matter that i'm sure all artists have or at some point will explore, and one that i have also looked into in the past. Last year i created some sculptures realating to the body, 'Stress' is a head carved from airated concrete with hands pulling apart the back of the skull to reveal a rope which comes down and forms a noose around the neck. 'be ever watchful' a mirror placed behind an eye which is looking through broken slates of a cupboard explored the idea of ones sence of self in regard to how one is viewed/ that no matter how alone one might think they are even in their most private moments there is always a sense of being 'watched'.



Art and the Body- Ah Xian




The Chinese-born artist migrated to Australia and mainly produces these life size busts and complete figures. They are made from porcelain and intricately hand-painted in traditional Chinese styles and symbols.

"Xian believes that Asian faces, with their features generally less pronounced than those of Europeans, are more sympathetic to porcelain and more relative to the material, which originated in China during the T'ang dynasty".1

Although his works reference immigration and sense of culture identity, I also feel they reference our sense of physical self and beauty. He uses the faces that are familiar to him, drenching them in cultural symbolism to the point that they become almost unrecognisable as human let alone Chinese. The long process that is undergone to fire and decorate and even the casting straight from actual people, all investigate our exploration of the human form and its endurance.

1.ArtMolds Sculpture Studio. "Ah Xian." http://www.artmolds.com/ali/halloffame/ah_xian.htm.

Art and the Body.








Last year i made a series of works all focusing on the body and its ability to cope with extreame trauma. while some focused on the power of the mind over the the body others focused on the raw images of the bodys healing process and the ability of modern medicine to enter the body in an intvasive and non-invasive way.

Art & The Body - The Body & Endurance - Tehching Hsieh

Tehching Hsieh, born 1950 in Taiwan, is a duration performance artist who has made 6 well known pieces 5 "one year performances" and a single 13 year piece
while the works main focus is on time and the duration for all his work, the body and endurance become evidently an equal focus in the works; One Year Performance 1978–1979 (Cage Piece), One Year Performance 1980–1981 (Time Clock Piece), One Year Performance 1981–1982 (Outdoor Piece), Art / Life: One Year Performance 1983–1984 (Rope Piece)

in each piece Hsieh follows a strict set of rules surrounding the purpose of the performance.

in One Year Performance 1978–1979 also known as cage piece, Hsieh locks himself in a wooden cage 11′6″×9′×8″ for one year, he is brought food by his friend Cheng Wei Kuong, he refused to converse, read, write, watch television or listen to the radio.

in One Year Performance 1980–1981 aka Time Clock Piece, Hsieh punches a time clock card every hour for 24 hours a day, every day for one year. when the card is punched a picture was taken of him and the images where then put into sequence into a video
the video can be seen here ( http://www.mediaartnet.org/works/one-year-performance/video/1/ )

One Year Performance 1981–1982 aka Outdoor Piece, Hsieh lives outside for a year refusing to enter any sort of building or shelter, including tents, vehicles or planes.

Art / Life: One Year Performance 1983–1984 aka Rope Piece, Hsieh and his friend Montano attach themselves to a single 8 foot long rope, while connected they had to stay in the same room but never touch each other until the year was up

each performance was not notarized by a lawyer.
the works each focus on the body and endurance as the artist places himself in a restricted space or action for a prolonged period of time causing serious harm to his body. this is best seen in "time clock piece" and "outdoor piece" as the effects of sleep deprivation and constant exposure to harsh environments cause physical and psychological stress.

as a twist M.River & T.Whid have created a reversal of Hsieh's One Year Performance 1978–1979 (Cage Piece), in which the audience is challenged to watch a one year video compilation of a modernised "cage piece". the idea was to take the original idea of the artists endurance and place it on the audience. so far only 23 people have watched the 1 year long footage
the video footage can be watched here ( http://www.turbulence.org/Works/1year/index.php )

Monday, August 17, 2009

Art and the body- Marina Abramovic




The House with the Ocean View, 2002, performance, Sean Kelly Gallery, New York, November, 2002

I thought this artist discussed in art and today was of much significance when discussing the ideas Eleanor Heartney has presented, especially in relation to the body used in performance art. As seen in the work below the body has become a medium and a subject matter in her works. She has explored the physical and mental limits of her being, she has withstood pain, exhaustion and danger in the quest for emotional and spiritual transformation. I find her performance art fascinating. As Heartney believes “performers throughout the world have found the human body to be an unusually versatile instrument. The artist’s works accentuate self-control, physical endurance, and risk.” which Abramovic has encompassed. Through the use of her body as a material Abramovic is able to take control of her “own subjectivity”. I found this work which was featured in the chapter fascinating. The fact she was able to live without eating, speaking, reading or writing seems unbelievable. It makes one wonder how much she was challenged mentally and physically.

http://www.skny.com/exhibitions/2002-11-15_marina-abramovi

Art & The Body - Julie Rrap




Julie Rrap has been a very influential Australian contemporary artist. A lot of her work revolves around the body and comments on the female figure throughout art history. Her performance piece 'Mind Over Matter' is no exception. The duration of the performance is approximately 17 minutes long, and in this time she uses the rubber heads from the series Eraser Head 1-6 to erase images depicting her naked body. The body then returns in the form of a left over, becoming fragmented and distorted.

Images from: http://www.roslynoxley9.com.au/artists/32/Julie_Rrap/

Art and the Body – Tania Bruguera

Tania Bruguera is a performance and installation artist from Cuba. She uses the body in her installations and videos to explore issues of power and control. One of her most famous works includes El Peso de la Culpa (the Burden of Guilt). This was a performance work in which Bruguera is standing before the Cuban flag which she had woven using human hair, with a butchered lamb hung around her neck. For a period of approximately 45 minutes, she mixed Cuban soil with water and ate it. She later explained that the performance alludes to a suicide-ritual practiced by the natives of Cuba. “By eating large quantities of earth, many took their own lives when faced with the threat of the Spanish conquistadores.” Displacement is a performance work in which Burguera incorporates a body which alludes to Nkisi Nkonde, who is an African figure, also used in Cuban spiritual practices. This figure was covered in mud and had rusted nails sprouting out of its limbs. Nkisi is a figure to which promises are made in exchange for granting petitions. Each nail is proof of these promises, and when a promise isn’t kept, the figure ‘awakens’ and goes in search of the person who broke this promise. In the performance the figure (a performer) is still for many hours, then stirs and eventually goes out into the streets in search of those who’ve broken their promises.

Art and Body: It is amazing what transgressive potential our body has as an art medium.



Last Tuesday two girls and I made a body based performance for studio concepts which involved one girl being covered with white paper. These were (19cm x 4cm) rectangles with the words from John Marsden’s 21st century prayer. Audience members were asked to come up and tear one off and read a line from the poem out loud. Our aim is summed up best by Heartney, “Freedom, Liberty and self determination are not abstract ideals, but achievements that write effects on our physical bodies” p220. It was great to read similar ideas like Zhang Huan’s In 12 Square Meters, 1994 piece. Where he covered himself in honey and sat for hours in a public toilet while flies covered his skin. In the end, body art is extraordinarily effective in reflecting our common humanity p238.

Heartney, Eleanor. Art and Today. London: Phaidon Press Limited, 2008

Sunday, August 16, 2009

Vito Acconci - The Body

‘At the beginning, setting the terms: if I specialize in a medium, I would be fixing a ground for myself, a ground I would have to be digging myself out of, constantly, as one medium was substituted for another – so, then, instead of turning toward “ground” I would shift my attention and turn to “instrument”, I would focus on myself as the instrument that acted on what ever ground was, from time to time, available.’

Body as instrument.

Instrument for “art doing” as opposed to “art experiencing”

“Art experiencing” is an assumption - a mere by-product of the completed form.

Vito Acconci, Step Piece, 1970.

102 Christopher Street; four months (February–April–July–November), 1970; 8AM each day.

Daily training makes for daily improvement.

The activity is left open; it is, in principle, a public performance.

Vito Acconci Steps into Performance (and Out) (1979)

1. Into Action

Excerpts taken from Theories and documents of Contemporary Art, Kristine Stiles and Peter Selz.

article review.. sorry its late!

Nicholas Zurbrugg article Installation Art – Essence and Existence examines the different elements that constitute a work with artistic merit or the innovative qualities ‘that widen the languages of creativity. Zurbrugg suggests Installations art’s position of autonomous ‘real-time’, as something that has the ability to co-exist through orchestrated time (duration), techno-time (data recording) or virtually outside of time as a separate and complete entity. These qualities of constructed ‘real-time’ and each works innate three dimensionality gives the artist the freedom to explore and assess new ways to develop and manipulate spatial impact on the viewer. Much Installation Art comes into existence through the artists desire to be self-governing and redefine the gallery space, whereby very exhibition is subject to the desires of the artist and the dimensions the installation is interfacing with, therefore the work also become self-documenting and self-conscious – its unique existence determines its essence. Zurbrugg emphasises that Installation Art has the potential to work on multiple levels of perception, participation, construction and idea/aesthetic essence, suggesting that we look towards the preceding modern movements of futurism, the Bauhaus experiments, dada, surrealism and constructivism in order to decipher the complex nature of the practice and stating that ‘many forms of contemporary Installation Art make historical sense as the systematic and technological realisation of modernist ‘dreams’’.

Zurbrugg reference to John Cage’s installation/performance-like happenings suggest the similarities between Installation Art and Performance and makes sense of the idea that because the audience is seen to be an active participant the work is always art-in progress and, therefore, is able to ‘consciously evade both pre-classification and post-classification’. Zurbrugg attitude seems to become a little more pessimistic when comparing the principles of Kurt Schwitters’ Merzbau 1924-23 and Marcel Duchamp’s Urinal 1917, suggesting that while Schwitters could be seen as the ‘precursor for the commemorative impulse in post-modern Installation Art, or those who take value seriously’ Duchamp’s initial impact have perhaps now given way to insipid and under considered ‘static’ installations. He further impresses that there is something insufficient about second-hand Duchampian shock-value installations through a statement by Joseph Beuys (Art monthly, 112 January 1988) that “the Silence of Duchamp is overrated” and that art should be “something which is related to humankinds creative structure and senses and to thought, feeling and the gaining of power”. This reference to the work of Joseph Beuys emphasises the notion that Installation art should be that of nostalgia, documentation, memorial and the artist and the audience (as one is the same). He moves on to point out that Installation Art with substance is generally in tune with current society and that kinetic works are most congruent. Perhaps again linking installation Art to performance – motion, or remarking that technology and progressive action is at the for-front of social values and must therefore be recognised as an artistic possibility. Zurbrugg poses a guideline to deciphering and recognising valid or cogent forms of installations and less valid substitutes, reinforcing that what advocates essence is Installation that actively invites the audience’s participation and contemplation.